Theory and Explanation in Geography
RGS-IBG Book Series
1. Edition October 2023
336 Pages, Softcover
Wiley & Sons Ltd
Short Description
Grounded in a generous reading of a multitude of critical approaches in human geography and their diverse conceptions of theory, Theory and Explanation in Geography draws upon cutting-edge debates on the mechanism-based approach to theory and explanation in analytical sociology, political science, and the philosophy of social sciences to inform current and future geographical thinking on theory. Detailing why and how mid-range explanatory theories can be better developed through causal mechanisms and relational thinking that have been revitalized in the social sciences, this is an essential read for academics, geographers, and scholars seeking unique perspective on an important facet of the field.
THEORY AND EXPLANATION IN GEOGRAPHY
"With this book Henry Yeung puts Geography back into the driver's seat of new theory development. Foregrounding mid-range theories and mechanism-based explanations, he offers a pragmatic approach that has the capacity to shape the wider social sciences for years to come. The timing of this intervention is pitch-perfect, as scholars search for ways to understand and intervene in an increasingly distrustful and polarized world."
--KATHARYNE MITCHELL, Distinguished Professor, University of California, Santa Cruz, USA
"In Theory and Explanation in Geography Yeung presents us with a rare thing - an argument for geographical theory with forms of causal explanation at its heart. The book is both modest and ambitious. Modest in its insistence on mid-level theory without a call for some new "turn" or advocacy for any particular approach. Ambitious in its insistence that existing theoretical traditions are inadequate or incomplete insofar as they lack causal explanatory power. Geographers will be inspired and/or infuriated by Yeung's arguments in this provocative and cogently argued call to theoretical arms for many years to come."
--Tim Cresswell, Ogilvie Professor of Geography, University of Edinburgh, UK
"Critical human geography possesses a distinctive theory culture--pluralist, creative, distributed, restless, contested--prone to "turning," wary of orthodoxies and fixed positions. In this original and provocative contribution, the leading economic geographer Henry Yeung steps out beyond his home turf to engage styles and practices of theorizing across this diverse field, carving out a new remit and rubric for middle-range theorizing."
--JAMIE PECK, Canadian Research Chair and Distinguished University Scholar, University of British Columbia, Canada
Grounded in a generous reading of a multitude of critical approaches in human geography and their diverse conceptions of theory, Theory and Explanation in Geography draws upon cutting-edge debates on the mechanism-based approach to theory and explanation in analytical sociology, political science, and the philosophy of social sciences to inform current and future geographical thinking on theory. This consolidated conceptual work represents an extension and much further development of the author's well-cited works on relational geography, critical realism and causal explanation, process-based methodology, globalization and the theory of global production networks, and "theorizing back" and situated knowledges that were published in leading journals in Geography.
The work has several chapters that identify new directions for Geography's current and future engagement with the wider social sciences and relevant research agendas in geographical thought. Its main chapters provide the necessary conceptual toolkits for mobilizing such an expanding research program in the 2020s and beyond. Compared to typical texts on geographical thought, this book is less retrospective and historical and more prospective in nature. Detailing why and how mid-range explanatory theories can be better developed through causal mechanisms and relational thinking that have been revitalized in the social sciences, Theory and Explanation in Geography is an essential read for academics, geographers, and scholars seeking unique perspective on an important facet of the field.
List of Figures x
Preface and Acknowledgement xi
1. Critical Human Geography Today: A Multitude of Approaches and Concepts? 1
Main Argument and Approach 5
Important Caveats: What This Book Is Not About 9
Key Considerations: Of/For Theory and Explanation 15
Chapter Outlines 20
Notes 26
2. Contemporary Geographical Thought: Theory and Explanation 36
Theory in Marxism 42
Theories in Poststructuralism and Post-Phenomenology/Posthumanism 44
Actor-Network Theory 45
Non-Representational Theory 50
Assemblage Theory 54
Post-Phenomenology and Posthumanism 62
Theories in Feminism and Postcolonialism 67
Feminist Theory 69
Postcolonial Theory 76
Notes 81
3. What Kind of Theory for What Kind of Human Geography? 95
Analytical Geographies: Theory and Explanation in Geography 97
From Concepts to Theories 99
From Theory to Explanation in Geography 103
Mid-Range Theories: Critical Realism, Causal Mechanisms, and Relational Thinking 107
What Realism -- Critical and/or Speculative? 109
Causal Mechanisms and Relational Thinking in Mid-Range Theories 116
Notes 121
4. Relational Theory 129
Relationality and Relational Thought in Contemporary Human
Geography 131
Relationality in Marxian and Institutional Geographies 134
Relational Thought in Poststructuralist, Feminist, and Postcolonial Geographies 139
Making Things Happen: Towards a Relational Theory 151
Rethinking Relational Thought: Relationality and Power 153
Causal Powers and Relationality in Relational Geometries 157
Notes 165
5. Mechanism and Process in Causal Explanation 173
Theorizing Mechanism in Causal Explanation 175
Reconceptualizing Mechanism, Process, and Context 178
Causal Theory and Actors 185
Processual Thought in Geography 188
From Process to Mechanism: Explanatory Theory/Theorizing in Geography 195
Why Neoliberalization? 196
Neoliberalization: What's in a Process and What Can Go Wrong? 199
Explaining Neoliberalism 'with Chinese Characteristics': How Might the Process-Mechanism Distinction Work? 203
Notes 207
6. Theorizing Globalization: Explanatory Theory, Situated Knowledges, and 'Theorizing Back' 212
Globalization as Geographical Processes 215
A Causal Theory of Global Production Networks: Explaining Globalization and Its Socio-Spatial Outcomes 221
Beyond Situated Knowledges: 'Theorizing Back' and Making Theory Work 228
Are Situated Knowledges Good Enough? 229
Theorizing Back: Strategic Coupling and Global Economic Geographies 235
Making Theory Work: The Trouble with Global Production Networks 240
Notes 245
7. What Kind of Geography for What Kind of Social Science? 252
Towards Analytical Geographies: Mid-Range Geographical Theories for Social Science 256
Beyond 'Academic Esotericism': Analytical Geographies for Public Engagement and Policy 261
Notes 266
References 269
Index 313